After a long day of farming, mining, and then passing out in a cave in Stardew Valley, it’s nice to have someone sweet waiting back at you for home. So they can scold you while nursing your fatigue. Thankfully, Stardew Valley lets you have that and more. The best romances in Stardew Valley can provide that warmth and soothing after a hard day’s work.
One of the game’s most enchanting features is the opportunity for players to embark on romantic journeys with the residents of Pelican Town. With several potential lovers to choose from, each with their distinct quirks and stories, selecting the perfect partner can be a delightful challenge. We’ll help you by ranking the best romances in Stardew Valley.
Shane – Battling Inner Demons
Shane’s journey is a rollercoaster of emotions, as you can help him confront his struggles with alcoholism and find meaning in life. His character arc is both compelling and dark, making him a divisive choice for many players.
Some might appreciate his development, while others find his initial hostility and ongoing battles with depression challenging to navigate. Still, that makes Shane a relatable adult and romantic option in Stardew Valley. Not everyone needs to be quirky and neurotypical; thus, Shane’s character hits close to home.
Elliott – The Mysterious Writer
Elliott, the enigmatic writer living by the beach, may appear one-dimensional at first. However, his journey to finding his place in the Valley can offer you a lateral perspective. That also automatically makes Elliot a similar character to your player character who also left the big city to find their place in the titular region.
While his character may not have the deeper hidden conflicts of others, players who appreciate his initial charm will find him to be one of Stardew Valley‘s best lovers. Besides, could you resist that hair?
Maru – The Scientific Genius
Maru is a stereotypical brilliant scientist who brings a touch of science fiction to the Valley with her inventive projects. Her storyline explores both her scientific endeavors and her family relationships. Maru’s unique fashion sense and passionate personality make her a favorite among players seeking an unconventional romance.
More importantly, she’s the right gal if you’re into nerdy partners who will wholeheartedly explore the world with you, dirty and dusty hobbies included.
Alex – The Misunderstood Jock
Alex, the athletic and misunderstood jock, is a lovable and sweet guy eager to impress. His struggles with his father’s toxic masculinity and his personal growth make him an appealing choice for many players. You can certainly nudge him in the right direction and watch him grow along with you in Stardew Valley.
However, his somewhat one-note personality may not satisfy those seeking a more complex partner. But the endearing journey to self-improvement can make this romantic path more personal. Besides, you need someone strong to help you on the farm, right?
Sam – The High School Sweetheart
Sam embodies the spirit of high school love, with his enthusiasm, charm, and skateboard antics. While he is endearing, his youthful nature may leave some players yearning for a more mature partner. Sam’s easy companionship and simple pleasures make him an ideal choice for those seeking a carefree romance.
There’s always a place for Sam especially for people who like the dude bro skater-boy facade. At least you’ll momentarily forget your aching late 20s knees while you’re with him.
Leah – The Artistic Soul
Leah’s artistic talents and independent personality make her a perfect choice for players who appreciate creativity and self-expression. Her character development, intertwined with her jealous ex, adds more depth and excitement to her storyline.
Her specific interests and initial standoffishness can be a hurdle for some players. But just like any artsy lover, you need only observe them in their natural habitat to see their beauty. And who knows, some of Leah’s appreciation for art and beauty might rub off on you.
Emily – The Quirky Free Spirit
One glance at that blue hair is enough to give players a glimpse of Emily’s soul. She wears her peculiarity on her skin. This one’s a classic INFJ who not only inspires others but also genuinely helps.
Emily’s eccentric and quirky personality sets her apart from the other candidates. Her commitment to helping others and embracing her peculiar interests make her a fascinating choice. While her eccentricities may border on the “homeopathic,” Emily’s character offers a refreshing and enjoyable romantic experience.
Sebastian – The Brooding Outsider
Just like Emily, Sebastian is easy to read on the outside. This shut-in computer nerd has the most erratic schedule out of all the romantic options in Stardew Valley, but if you’re into couch potato dates and are in need of a gaming duo, there’s no better lover.
Sebastian’s brooding and rebellious demeanor may deter some players initially, but those who take the time to uncover his layers will find a rewarding romance. His character development and introverted interests make him a standout choice. Sebastian’s angsty charm adds depth to the Valley’s romantic options. He doesn’t mind being your emo-gamer BF.
Abigail – The Adventurous Geek
Speaking of gaming, Abigail is sort of the female version of Sebastian. The difference is, she’s a lot more outgoing and is less emo. Well, probably not less, since she’s into the Wicca (pretty cool).
Abigail’s adventurous and free-spirited personality, coupled with her love for gaming and the occult, make her a fan favorite. Her quirky nature and memorable heart events provide a rich and engaging romantic journey. While her storyline may falter at times, Abigail’s character remains captivating and off-track as a gamer goth GF.
Penny – The Gentle and Compassionate Soul
Claiming the top spot in our ranking is Penny, the gentle and compassionate schoolteacher. Her selfless nature and dedication to her family can tug at the heartstrings of many players. Penny’s very character embodies kindness and warmth, making her ideal for those seeking a wholesome and loving partner with a neutral disposition for any cultural preference.
Despite her challenging circumstances, she radiates positivity and remains true to herself, making her the best spouse and best girl in Stardew Valley. And you’ll know she’ll be a great parent since she has plenty of experience dealing with kids.